Vedic and Western Astrology: Key Differences

Summary:  Key differences between Vedic Astrology and Western Astrology discussed. The Vedic  system differs dramatically from the Western one in its origins (via Vedic cognition), paradigms (such as predictive, preventive, karmic, coded information – not planetary forces)  and methodology (such as use of only 9 planets, sidereal zodiac, functional benefics, Mahadasha predictive periods, etc.).

Different Systems – Different Strengths

If we look at both Vedic Astrology and Western Astrology, we find both systems have their unique strengths. 

Western Astrology tends to focus more on psychological factors and the mind, so a Western birth-chart is a good starting point for counselling. If we are seeking insights into our thoughts, feelings and psychological inner-self then Western Astrology has a lot to offer.

Vedic Astrology on the other hand, focuses more on karma and predicting what karmas will manifest in our lifetime and when those effects will occur. It is unique in that it offers remedial measures to greatly lessen returning negative karmas. So, Vedic Astrology is both predictive and preventive, and offers real solutions to many of life’s problems.

Although the above are broad generalisations (which astrologers from both traditions would doubtless ‘enjoy’ debating), they highlight the different emphasis between Western and Vedic Astrology.

Vedic Astrology – Predictive and Preventive

Jyotish is predictive. It identifies possible benefits and obstacles in all life areas  – such as our health, home, wealth and income, children, career, relationships, spiritual growth, etc. [1] . It predicts both positive, and also more challenging, periods in the future. It therefore attempts to detect a person’s returning karmas and predicts when these are likely to manifest.

Jyotish is preventive. It uses a wide range of remedial measures deigned to influence an individual’s returning karma. This ability to ‘prescribe remedies’ to re-balance planetary energies, as seen from a birth-chart, is a unique feature of Jyotish. So, Vedic Astrology is, at its most fundamental level, involved with ‘karmic engineering’ .

Jyotish astrology also employs techniques for predicting the optimum time to commence major undertakings e.g. starting a business, getting married, building a house, etc. This is called Muhurta. As they say: ‘Well begun is half done’.

Jyotish Astrology: Cognized – Not Developed

Unlike Western Astrology, which was developed by people over centuries, Jyotish was cognized. In Vedic cognition a great seer or Rishi (in this case Maharishi Parashara) connected his individual consciousness to the ‘cosmic computer’ and ‘downloaded’ the whole of Vedic Astrology’s knowledge and techniques. Jyotish Astrologers view their subject with great reverence – seeing it as a gift from the Divine to help alleviate the suffering of the people.

Vedic Astrology comes from the same traditions as Yoga, Meditation, Pranayama, Ayurveda and Vastu.

Vedic Astrology Only Needs to Use Nine ‘Planets’

Traditional Jyotish Astrology uses only nine Grahas – roughly translated as the nine ‘planets’ – the seven visible ‘planets’ up to and including Saturn, plus the two nodes of the Moon. Unlike Western Astrology, it does not ‘use’ the planets beyond Saturn simply because it does not need to!

In Vedic Astrology,  the information needed for prediction is encoded in the arrangements of the nine planets at the time of birth. (The subsequent transit of planets usually has a reduced ‘weighting’ in predictions).

The arrangement of the seven ‘planets’ (and the two nodes of the moon) between the twelve signs, twelve houses and twenty-seven stellar constellations (Nakshatras) is in effect, just highly coded information. The transit of planets, as they appear to move through signs and ‘houses’, is also seen as codified information.

If you find a ‘Jyotish Astrologer’ who uses Neptune, Pluto and Uranus they are not following Traditional Jyotish Astrology but have mixed up the 2 systems. They have failed to understand the above points (re: coded information)!

Because Vedic Astrology sees the universe and all the beings in it as part of an interconnected whole – a field of energy, order and ‘intelligence’, it deals with coded information. This concept is explored further in our article on ‘The Vedic Model of Reality’

We should note that Western astrology is more ‘Newtonian’ and mechanistic in that it seems to suggest all planets emit some type of ‘force’ (as yet undiscovered by science) that affects humans on Earth. So every time astronomers discover a new celestial object in our solar system, Western Astrology has to adapt and devise astrological properties for the newly found object. Jyotish regards this as unnecessary. It simply has no need to invent ‘Planetary Forces’ which affect people – as Jyotish just deals with coded information based on planetary positions and not ‘forces’ emanating from planets. 

A Unique System of Time Based Predictions – The Mahadashas

Jyotish uses the totally unique Mahadasha system of prediction to delineate time periods of major karmic influence. In common with Western Astrology it also uses transits, but their effect is usually of much less importance than the Mahadashas.

Mahadasha periods are a key to successful prediction. This is where the static elements of the planets in the houses and signs in the birth-chart interact with the dynamic element of the Mahadashas to produce time dependent predictions: i.e. ‘what happens’ and ‘when it happens’.

Ascendant of Key Importance in Jyotish

In Vedic Astrology an individual’s ascendant (the sign that was rising on the eastern horizon at the time of birth) is of fundamental importance. The ‘Sun sign’ used by Western Astrology is of relatively little importance.

The ascendant is particularly important in determining the appropriate ‘planetary remedies’ prescribed in Jyotish. It is also vital in that it determines which planets become functional benefics / malefics for that individual.

Jyotish Always Uses the Sidereal Zodiac

Jyotish uses the same twelve signs of the zodiac that the Western system uses. However, in the case of Jyotish this is permanently referenced to the ‘fixed stars’ and does not move (as the Western Tropical Zodiac does)!  Therefore Jyotish uses the fixed, or Sidereal Zodiac. In practical terms this means planetary positions in the two systems are not the same.  Planets can change signs in the two systems.

The following might come as a surprise to some Western Astrologers. The starting point of the Western Astrologer’s (Tropical) zodiac is referenced to the movable equinox points, not the fixed stars. This Tropical zodiac moves slowly through the sky against the background of the fixed stars. This means that the part of the zodiac called ‘Aries’ in the Western system is not actually linked to a particular constellation and changes over a period of time. The angular difference (now around 24 degrees) between the starting points of the two different zodiacs is called the ‘Ayanmsha’.

Traditional Jyotish astrology always involves the ‘equal house concept’ – every house occupies 30 degrees of the sky and houses correspond exactly with signs in the sidereal zodiac. The Western system often uses unequal angular house divisions.

Jyotish Uses ‘Functional Benefics’ and ‘Functional Malefics’

In addition to their natural benefic, or natural malefic characteristics, planets in Jyotish take on other characteristics, for better or worse, depending on what houses they ‘own’ or ‘rule’ in an individual’s birth-chart. There is no equivalent concept in Western Astrology.

For example, a natural malefic such as Mars, can become a very positive influence indeed for a person with a Leo (sidereal) ascendant. Similarly, a natural benefic such as Venus can become a very negative influence for someone with a Pisces (sidereal) ascendant.

This concept is vital for proper chart interpretation and also for ‘prescribing’ planetary remedies such as wearing certain gemstones. If you are a Western astrologer and want more information please refer to our articles: ‘Functional Benefic and Malefic Planets’ and ‘Functional Benefics and Malefics for All Ascendants’.

Footnotes

[1]  Jyotish deals with predictions involving the four key areas of life as defined by the Vedas: Artha, Dharma, Kama and Moksha.

Artha covers ‘wealth’ (money and prosperity, ‘wealth’ of children, ‘wealth’ of knowledge, ‘wealth’ of food, ‘wealth’ of health, etc.). Dharma covers duty, character, actions that will be evolutionary and follow natural law (e.g. type of career), etc. Kama means desire, so it covers relationships, all types of desires, pleasures of the senses, etc. Moksha covers spiritual and personal growth towards Self-realization.


Additional Information on Vedic Astrology

Article on Vedic Astrology from Wikipedia

Introduction to Jyotish. A range of articles for people entirely new to Vedic Astrology. Including: Introduction, FAQs, Origins and Karmic Implications.

Key Concepts in Jyotish. Articles covering the Sidereal Zodiac, Planetary Forces, Forecasting Analogies and ‘Planetary Antidotes’.

For Western Astrologers. Articles examining major differences between the two systems and the paradigm shift needed by Western Astrologers wanting to understand the subject.

Learn Jyotish. An extensive collection of articles covering key facts, concepts and methods. Aimed at ‘foundation level’ students. Includes essential information needed before beginning chart interpretations. Covering: Chart Formats, Planets, Houses, Mahadasha Periods, Transits, Aspects, Birth-time Errors, Natural and Functional Benefics / Malefics, Chart Interpretation Basics, etc.